Vienna, Issue 43

In December 2019, we spent two weeks in Vienna. We wanted to visit its famous Christmas markets. Also, I had to see what made Vienna the world’s most livable city. Vienna has now topped Mercer’s Quality of City Living Index for ten years in a row. It is also a perennial leader in both Monocle Magazine and The Economist livability indexes.

It took us just sixteen minutes from airport to downtown on the very clean City Airport Train(“CAT”). We arrived at a U-Bahn (subway) and S-Bahn (local train) transport hub. For all of our stay, we went everywhere by public transit or on foot. It was clean, convenient, safe, and quick. The transport hub was very close to the apartment we had rented. So, we checked our bags in convenient lockers at the CAT terminus. The service is complimentary with the ticket.

This left us free to start exploring our nearby neighbourhood. Our apartment was five minutes from St. Stephens Cathedral. Transit hub to cathedral to busy pedestrian streets, we saw little of the visible homelessness that plagues North American cities. Viennese made up the vast majority of people everywhere. They strolled the streets enjoying their city, frequenting the restaurants and bars, and visiting the Christmas markets. Everyone seemed to have money to spend. So, we thought that average incomes must be high. It was only later that I discovered that affordable housing was the core cause of available discretionary income. The city of Vienna owns or controls 48% of the urban housing stock. As a consequence, rents are much lower and disposable income, net of housing costs, much higher.

The origins of social housing in Vienna

The world’s longest building spans four tram stops, 1,382 units built between 1927 & 1930

The so-named Red Vienna era started at the end of the World War 1, the time of Austria’s First Republic. It ended in 1938 with Nazi Germany’s annexation of Austria. However, between 1923 and 1934, the City’s government built 66,402 social housing units. Perimeter block development was the predominant format in that era. The properties feature large gateways and interior courtyards. Also, many have shops, swimming pools, and kindergartens. These well-maintained properties remain part of Vienna’s residential inventory.

Vienna re-started its housing program two years after the end of World War 2. It continues to add 4300 new units to its inventory every year. Toronto, a city twice the size of Vienna, has 60,000 social housing units and considers a plan to add 4000 units a year for 10 years ambitious. However, this will not do very much for the 81,000 families waiting for subsidized housing. New York City has 175,000 social housing units, only 41% of the Vienna inventory in a city more than five times the size.

Municipal Housing Units Owned220,000
Municipally Controlled Housing Units through Limited Profit Developers (LPDs)200,000
Total Municipally Owned and Controlled Housing Units420,000
Approximate Percentage of Housing Stock Owned or Controlled48%
Percentage of Vienna’s population in Owned / Controlled Housing60%
Average rentsC$750 pm
Targeted rental rates as a percentage of income, municipally owned and controlled=/< 20 to 25%
Average rents as a percentage of income overall27%
Units added annually4,300
Annual budget – social housing for new units and for refurbishmentC$877 million
Vienna – Snapshot of Social Housing Inventory

The Role of Limited Profit Developers

Vienna introduced the limited-profit developer program in the 1980s. These privately owned developers collaborate with municipal government to develop new social housing.

The Process:

  1. City assembles and buys land and then,
  2. Solicits proposals from Limited Profit Developers. These are evaluated on the basis of:
    1. Architectural quality
    2. Environmental performance
    3. Social sustainability
    4. Economic parameters
  3. Successful proponents buy the relevant land assembly from the city at an affordable price
  4. City grants loans for both the land purchase and vertical build at low interest rates and for extended terms 

Additional Guidelines

Subsidized rental to market rent penthouses
Wohnpark Neue Donau which is built across an expressway

The City of Vienna requires that 50% of the residential units must be leased to lower income tenants. Generally, the remaining units are leased to moderate income earners. In Wohnpark Neue Donau there is everything from subsidized rental to free market penthouses.  The Austrian Federation of Limited-Profit Housing Associations (GBV)   has oversight responsibility. It performs compulsory Limited Profit Housing Act audits to ensure LPD adherence to guidelines and comparative performance. 

High income, middle-income, low-income people live in the same places. As such, addresses do not predict the income, race, or religion. Racial and income ghettos are avoided.

The World’s most livable city

Both The Economist and Monocle Magazine rate Vienna as the worlds most livable city. There are many elements that contribute to its ranking:

  • Excellent international connectivity
  • A stable and growing economy
  • Quality public transit
  • International rail service

However, its affordable housing strategy contributes most to Vienna’s top placement on “quality of life” rankings. Successive generations have continued to support a policy of good, secure housing at a reasonable price as a basic human right. The Viennese believe that a populace un-fettered by housing fears and costs will be better educated, more creative, more industrious, and community minded. There will be more money to spend in the local economy. It is hard to argue with success. Ten years at the top of Mercer’s Quality of Living Index is a measure of that success.

The usual reminders: 

  • Buy better, buy less, reduce, repair, reuse and recycle 
  • Shop local, support local businesses, buy from local farms, and support local artisans and manufacturers
  • Wear face masks where required, wash your hands, practice social distancing, hydrate, and exercise
  • Cancel Facebook and Instagram!

Lisbon – A City on the Rise?

March 7, 2023

Lisbon’s seven hills and waterfront make it visually spectacular. The second oldest capital in Europe, the city has energy. Busy streets and squares, full restaurants, and vibrant night life – the city pulsates. And, the population seems young. All signs of a city on the rise? Earthquake A 1755 earthquake destroyed 85% of the city […]

Cities and Towns, The Affordable Housing Problem

February 8, 2023

People living on the street have come to symbolize the global housing crisis but they are only the tip of the iceberg. While the examples of Finland and Houston demonstrate a focussed plan pursued diligently can resolve the housing situation for the chronically homeless, addressing the affordable housing problem is much more complex.  Defining Affordability […]

I Love to Dance

January 29, 2023

I love to dance. This is not something new for me. I can’t remember when I didn’t like to move to the music. My first memories of watching others dance come from my childhood in Cape Breton where I would watch the adults square dance. Then, there were the step dancers who would often accompany […]

Cities and Towns 8, A City is About People

January 19, 2023

Kings Cross, once a thriving industrial and transport centre in London, was effectively closed  off  to the public by the end of the 20th century.   Then in 1996, the decision was made to move the British terminus for the Channel Tunnel Rail Link from Waterloo to St-Pancras. The landowner saw a re-development opportunity for […]

NEOM - the Wall

Cities and Towns 7, Cities and Towns Evolve

January 8, 2023

I have postulated that cities and towns evolve. That towns and villages first grow in areas where the basics to support life were plentiful. Typically, that means good agricultural land and good access to water. Other valuable considerations include safety, and resilience. The bonus – access to trade routes.  Walt Disney and the Fully Formed […]

Christmas Poem 2022

December 22, 2022

A Visit from Saint Nicholas A Poem by Jonathan Potter – December 2022 ‘Twas the first mask-free Christmas, when all through the stores  The vaccinated children were spewing their spores;The shoppers were eagerly starting to riotAs the introverts longed for some quarantine quiet. The public healthcare workers were tracing the pathOf the flu and RSV, […]